Smoke Detector vs Carbon Monoxide Detector: The Differences Explained

If you’re weighing up various security and safety measures for your home and you adopt a smoke detector vs carbon monoxide detector comparison approach towards protecting against fire safety, know this. Smoke detectors and carbon monoxide detectors are not interchangeable. They do not perform the same function, and actually detect different hazards to your home and family.

A smoke detector identifies and alerts to visible airborne smoke particles from house fires, often caused by cooking mistakes, electrical faults or unattended candles.

On the other hand, a carbon monoxide detector senses colourless and odourless (and potentially lethal) gas leaking from fuel-burning appliances like heaters or gas stoves. Both detectors play a vital role in fire safety and human health by alerting you quickly, so you can act fast before things get out of hand.

Knowing what each device does means you install them in the right places and reduce the dangers in your home.

Let’s first look at smoke detectors; what they do and how they work.

A smoke detector is a safety device that detects smoke particles in your home and alerts you to potential fire hazards. Smoke detectors come in two different options: photoelectric and ionisation smoke detectors.

Photoelectric smoke alarms/detectors have a photoelectric sensor that emits a small light beam. When visible smoke from smouldering fires enters the chamber, it scatters this beam and triggers the alarm. Then you have ionisation smoke detectors, which use a small amount of radioactive material to detect smoke from flaming fires faster.

As smoke rises, it’s always wise to install smoke alarms on ceilings or high walls. Testing the alarm with the test button helps prevent false alarms and ensures the alarm works during a real fire.

What is a Carbon Monoxide Detector?

Then you have carbon monoxide (CO) detectors. As the name suggests, these devices detect carbon monoxide gas from fuel-burning appliances like gas heaters, ovens and gas-powered hot water systems.

“Why do I need a carbon monoxide detector?” I hear you ask. Simply because, unlike natural gas, carbon monoxide is colourless and odourless. Therefore, it’s basically undetectable with just the human senses alone.

Exposure to high levels of carbon monoxide gas can cause serious health issues and even fatal carbon monoxide poisoning. These detectors use electrochemical sensors to measure carbon monoxide levels in the air. When the sensor detects dangerous levels, the alarm sounds. That becomes your sign to get outdoors and get fresh air immediately.

Installing carbon monoxide alarms near sleeping areas, living spaces, and rooms with fuel-burning appliances that produce carbon monoxide gives you the best possible detection and protects your family’s health.

Knowing the differences between a smoke detector vs carbon monoxide detector means you can make informed choices about how to best protect your home and family:

• Detection methods: Smoke detectors use photoelectric sensors or ionisation technology to detect smoke particles, while carbon monoxide detectors use electrochemical sensors to identify invisible gas.
• Purpose: Smoke alarms alert to house fires, smouldering fires or rapidly flaming fires, depending on whether you have photoelectric detectors or ionisation smoke detectors. Carbon monoxide alarms warn of CO gas leaks to protect you from the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning.
• Placement: As smoke rises, you’re better off mounting smoke detectors high on ceilings or walls. However, height is less important for carbon monoxide detector installation. More important is keeping the CO detector away from gas appliances at a distance of between 1 and 3 metres.
• Alarm triggers: Smoke alarms trigger when smoke enters their sensors. CO alarms trigger when they detect dangerous levels of carbon monoxide gas.

Knowing these differences means you install correctly and have full protection from smoke and carbon monoxide exposure.

As luck would have it, you can actually buy and install combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms. These offer a convenient solution for your home’s smoke and carbon monoxide dangers, and come with numerous benefits, including:

• Dual protection: They have multiple sensors, photoelectric smoke detectors and electrochemical sensors to detect visible smoke particles and invisible carbon monoxide gas.
• Simplified maintenance: Having both smoke and CO detection in one alarm means installation and maintenance are easier, and you have fewer devices to test or replace.
• Interconnected alarms: You can buy wireless, battery-powered alarms or models that an electrician can hard-wire to your home’s electrical system. When one alarm sounds, all interconnected alarms sound, alerting occupants throughout the home.
• Advanced features: Many combination alarms have additional safety features like digital displays, battery backup, remote control, smart detector capabilities and even strobe lights for people with hearing impairments.

Invest in combination alarms and your home gets full and convenient fire safety and carbon monoxide detection.

Importance of Installation by a Licensed Electrician

Installing smoke and carbon monoxide alarms correctly is crucial for home safety, so engage a licensed electrician. In fact, you’re legally required to use a professional electrician to install hard-wired models.

Professional electricians understand and comply with the manufacturer’s instructions and local building codes, so they will install alarms and detectors in the right places for the best possible performance. For interconnected alarms, proper wiring is key. Incorrect DIY installation can cause malfunctions, false alarms or even power failures that leave your home exposed.

A licensed electrician will check that all connections are secure, batteries function as backups during power outages, and the alarm sounds the right signal during detection. Ultimately, professional installation gives you peace of mind knowing your home and family are protected from fires and dangerous levels of carbon monoxide gas.

To get the most out of smoke and carbon monoxide alarms, avoid these common mistakes.

Many homeowners neglect to test regularly, so they run the risk of leaving alarms inoperative during an emergency. Test your alarms monthly by pressing the test button, and replace batteries annually. Another common error is incorrect placement.

Smoke alarms should be installed high on walls or ceilings; keep them out of kitchens too to avoid nuisance beeping from your smoke alarm. Meanwhile, always install carbon monoxide detectors at everyday breathing level.

Ignoring the manufacturer’s instructions and not replacing devices at recommended intervals can also reduce protection. Painting or covering alarms can also impair sensors and delay alerts.

Understanding these mistakes will help you avoid them. Avoiding said mistakes and correctly maintaining alarms will help you enjoy fast and accurate detection and increase your family’s safety at home.

Clearly understanding the difference between smoke detectors and carbon monoxide detectors is key to home safety. It’s important to understand that it’s not about smoke detector vs carbon monoxide detector, but about how they work together to provide a well-rounded protection.

Both smoke alarms and carbon monoxide alarms serve different but equally important purposes, detecting visible smoke particles from fires and invisible carbon monoxide gas leaks, respectively.

Proper placement, regular maintenance and professional installation by a licensed electrician are the essential steps to ensure these alarms work when needed. Consider combination smoke and carbon monoxide alarms for full coverage and peace of mind.

In the end, it comes down to being informed and proactive about fire safety and carbon monoxide detection. This will help protect your family from dangers and create a healthier home environment.

Please note: Thanks for reading our blog “Smoke Detector vs Carbon Monoxide Detector: The Differences Explained”. This information is provided for advice purposes only. Regulations differ from state to state, so please consult your local authorities or an industry professional before proceeding with any work. See our Terms & Conditions here.